To keep its hopes alive in the 99th edition of “The Game,” Rye football needed to drive 99 yards.
Trailing by a touchdown late in the fourth quarter, sophomore Max Cabrera intercepted a Harrison pass to give the Garnets the ball on their own 1-yard line. The turnover gave Rye a shot at a dramatic rally against its long-time rivals, but driving the entire length of the Nugent Stadium field proved too tough a task.
The Garnets crossed midfield before stalling out in Husky territory, turning the ball over on downs and losing 21-14 on Saturday afternoon.
The storylines for this edition of “The Game” look quite different than years past. Rye had won 22 of the past 25 meetings, but Harrison (6-1) is off to its best start since 2022, and Rye (4-3) hasn’t lost this many regular-season games since 2012.
And yet, entering the game, the Garnets had a chance to leapfrog their rivals in the standings with a win. Early on, Rye appeared primed to beat Harrison for a third straight season. The Huskies’ opening drive barely made it past midfield before a turnover on downs.
On the Garnets’ first possession, sophomore quarterback Johnny Shoemaker completed passes to senior captain Luke Denvir and Cabrera, then ended the drive with a scamper into the end zone for a 7-0 lead.
The Huskies fired back on the next drive with a 30-yard pass from quarterback TJ Haynes to Mikey Braiotta to even the score.
The contest was back-and-forth throughout the first half. The Garnets again marched down the field, and Shoemaker found senior captain Jagger Fenton for his second receiving score of the season.
Before the end of the half, Harrison tied it up again. Another pass from Haynes to Braiotta put the Huskies inches from the goal line, and tailback Jason Crupi knotted it up at 14 entering the break.
The second half felt like an entirely different ballgame. The weather changed quickly, as the sun started peeking out, a once-volatile crowd turned to a light murmur, and the Garnet offensive pace slowed to a methodical jog.
The next seven minutes featured about 30 yards of total offense. Rye gradually marched down the field before a Shoemaker pass to Ryan Hess on 4th and 3 fell short of the first-down marker.
Harrison took over deep in its own territory, then whipped the maroon-clad portion of the crowd into a sudden frenzy. On the third play of the drive, Crupi maneuvered past the Garnet defensive front for the run of his life, an 80-yard sprint into the end zone that gave the Huskies their first lead of the game.
It was the longest scoring play allowed by Rye all season and left the home crowd in a stunned silence for the remaining 16 minutes of the game. There was still plenty of time left, but the Garnets were unable to turn productive drives into points.
After a pass from Shoemaker to senior Luke Ontaneda put the Garnets in scoring position, a fourth-down interception just short of the end zone put the ball back in Husky hands before the start of the fourth quarter.
Harrison was almost able to make it a two-score game, until Cabrera’s clutch interception gave the Garnets life with 10 minutes remaining. The offense proceeded to slowly march downfield again, with Shoemaker hitting four different receivers on a drive that propelled them past midfield.
With two minutes remaining, the Garnets were faced with 4th and 6 at the Harrison 35-yard line. A conversion would keep their hopes alive, and a Husky stop would seal their fate.
After the ball was snapped, Shoemaker quickly popped up, and without much hesitation, fired a pass to junior Calvin Timchak. It was just out of his reach, stopping the Garnets in their tracks and setting up victory formation for the Huskies.
For Rye, the third loss of the season is arguably the toughest to swallow, considering the opponent. It also poses a question decades of Garnet teams have rarely asked: will they be playing postseason ball after next week?
The Garnets can clinch a berth with a win against Clarkstown North (5-2) in Friday’s regular-season finale. A Rye loss, combined with a Yorktown win over Harrison, could open the door for a surprisingly early end to the season. Yorktown is only 2-5, but would hold a tiebreaker over Rye for having a better record against common opponents.
It’s an unusual place for the Garnets to be, but the team’s fate is still in its own hands. With a win Friday, Rye’s section title defense would likely go through Somers or Clarkstown South – two teams that beat the Garnets earlier this season. But with a legendary coach on the sidelines and flashes of potential throughout the year, Rye is never a name anyone wants to line up against in November.


