How New York High School Rankings Went Haywire This Year

State's refusal to share advanced placement data with U.S. News and World Report creates shake-up in rankings, including a 20-spot drop for Rye High School.
Rye High School

New York state’s school rankings in U.S. News and World Report were turned upside down this year, thanks to a decision by the state not to share advanced placement data with the company. 

Schools ranked in the top six of Westchester County received at least a partial score in college readiness because they offer International Baccalaureate programs. Rye just started offering its IB program last school year, and the program takes two years for students to complete. 

New York was one of four states to withhold AP scores, hurting all of the state’s school rankings and prompting a lawsuit against New York Education Commissioner Betty Rosa. 

Out of more than 1,300 New York public schools, Rye ranked No. 57 – a drop of 20 spots from last year. Nationally, the school ranked No. 5,027 out of 18,000 public schools, also a significant drop from the high rankings the district is accustomed to.  

“New York state wouldn’t allow some data to be submitted because of student privacy concerns,” Rye City School District Superintendent Tricia Murray told The Record. “The college readiness score they give is based on the number of AP courses a district has, and they didn’t have any of that data, so our college readiness says N/A.” 

U.S. News and World Report – a media company that uses data to rank educational institutions, businesses and more – provides a scorecard for each school based on college readiness, college curriculum breadth, state assessment proficiency and performance, underserved student performance, and graduation rate. 

The organization’s rankings compare 10,000-plus schools across the country and catches the attention of district officials and families, and has even been known to influence property values. 

Murray said the rankings, especially with this year’s absence of AP data, are not an accurate analysis of the academic programming in Rye. 

“While we recognize that rankings can provide one perspective on a school’s performance, they do not tell the full story of the educational experience we provide our students,” she said. 

In the recent rankings, Rye sat behind 11 other Westchester County public schools: Harrison (4), Dobbs Ferry (7), Yonkers (9), Somers (17), Port Chester (19), Woodlands (24), Edgemont (33), Scarsdale (40), Briarcliff (44), Bronxville (50), and Hastings (53). 

Rye’s rating in math, reading, and science are all higher than Harrison’s, but because the rankings did not include AP data, Rye’s college readiness score was effectively a zero. That left Rye’s overall rating 27 points lower than Harrison’s 98.82 mark.  

Rye boasts high proficiency levels in math (97 percent), reading (97 percent), and science (94 percent) – as well as a 99 percent graduation rate, which is “well above state median,” according to U.S. News and World Report. 

With a total score of 71.99 out of 100, the school is still eligible to display a U.S. News Best High School Award Badge recognizing educational excellence. 

“We remain incredibly proud of the diverse academic opportunities, programs and experiences available to Rye students and continue to focus on providing a rigorous, well-rounded education that prepares every student for success,” Murray said. 

If U.S. News and World Report were to use the same methodology for its rankings next year, Rye’s addition of an IB program could restore the district to its usual standing higher up the state and nationwide rankings. 

FILED UNDER: