OFF THE CUFF: August 21, 2015

Harper Lee’s new (well, old, but new) novel caused quite a stir. Some think the whole thing is the height of commercialism. For sure there was a lot of pre-publication hype going on. It’s also been a cause for confusion.

August 20, 2015
3 min read

off-the-cuff THHarper Lee’s new (well, old, but new) novel caused quite a stir. Some think the whole thing is the height of commercialism. For sure there was a lot of pre-publication hype going on. It’s also been a cause for confusion.

By Allen Clark

off-the-cuff LARGEHarper Lee’s new (well, old, but new) novel caused quite a stir. Some think the whole thing is the height of commercialism. For sure there was a lot of pre-publication hype going on. It’s also been a cause for confusion.

The 1960 classic “To Kill a Mockingbird” is arguably one of America’s favorite novels. It has sold more than 30 million copies in 40 languages worldwide and won the Pulitzer Prize. The 1962 movie won three Academy Awards, including Best Actor for Gregory Peck. Lawyer Atticus Finch is one of the most influential, moral, and idealistic figures in literature.

So, what are we to think when Lee’s original draft, now called “Go Set a Watchman,” is published 55 years later, and Atticus in his later years is a segregationist, mouthing bigoted sentiments like “Do you want Negroes by the carload in our schools and churches and theaters? Do you want them in our world?”

One of the concerns has been whether Harper Collins somehow “forced” the aging Ms. Lee to publish this version. We may never know for sure; however, she did seem to have reservations. The key issue to me is, whoever said first drafts were worthy of publication – back when they were written, or a half-century later? There are very few works of art that emerge Venus-like from inspiration without a good portion of sweat.

Back in 1957, when she submitted this draft to J.B. Lippincott, she felt it was her best shot. Had her publishers recognized it as good enough to publish, they would have. But they didn’t. As Wall Street Journal critic Sam Sacks commented,  “Go Set a Watchman” was a practice run for “To Kill a Mockingbird.” Based on all the reviews, it would seem most critics think it should have stayed that way.

Perhaps the biggest concern about “Watchman” is the precipitous fall of Atticus Finch. Maybe the reading (and I would have to add movie-going) public acquires rights of ownership in cases like this. With the matter still a major cocktail-party conversation topic, I’m waiting to see what new safe-deposit-box discoveries publishers will turn up next.

Will Swiss nursemaid Maria be recast as a beer-guzzling, mean-hearted keeper of the von Trapp children? Will Heidi now be a sloppy, sullen spendthrift who steals goats and money from her friend’s blind grandmother?

Will Ahab turn out to be a member of Green Peace? Will Tiny Tim end up a selfish, hedonistic hedge fund manager? Will Raskolnikov actually become a founder of the Salvation Army?

Jane Austen had an earlier draft of “Pride and Prejudice.” What if Lizzy Bennet really was a woman of the night, rejecting her hopeless mother, distant father, and miserable rest of the Bennet clan?

Most distressing, does Lassie  not come home? What do we think when she forms a wild-dog pack that ravages the hillside farms of Yorkshire? (By the way, rumor has it Lady Gaga will star in the movie version as Priscilla.)

I can’t wait.

 

Filed Under:
Subscribe and get freshly baked articles. Join the community!
Begin typing your search above and press return to search. Press Esc to cancel.

kuwin

iplwin

my 11 circle

betway

jeetbuzz

satta king 786

betvisa

winbuzz

dafabet

rummy nabob 777

rummy deity

yono rummy

shbet

kubet

winbuzz

daman games

winbuzz

betvisa

betvisa

betvisa

baji999

marvelbet

krikya

Dbbet

Nagad88

Babu88

Six6s

Bhaggo

Elonbet

yono rummy

rummy glee

rummy perfect

rummy nabob

rummy modern

rummy wealth

jeetbuzz

iplwin

yono rummy

rummy deity

rummy app

betvisa

lotus365

hi88

8day

97win

n88

red88

king88

j88

i9bet

good88

nohu78

99ok

bet168

betvisa

satta king

satta matta matka

betvisa

mostplay

4rabet

leonbet

pin up

mostbet

rummy modern

Fastwin Login

Khela88

Fancywin

Jita Ace

Betjili

Betvisa

Babu88

jeetwin

nagad88

jaya9

joya 9

khela88

babu88

babu888

mostplay

marvelbet

baji999

abbabet

Jaya9

Mostbet

MCW

Jeetwin

Babu88

Nagad88

Betvisa

Marvelbet

Baji999

Jeetbuzz

Mostplay

Jwin7

Melbet

Betjili

Six6s

Krikya

Jitabet

Glory Casino

Betjee

Jita Ace

Crickex

Winbdt

PBC88

R777

Jitawin

Khela88

Bhaggo