OFF THE CUFF: August 22, 2014

How often have you read a book review, say in The Sunday New York Times, and run into a phrase like, “Author John Doe, in this prescient new novel…”?  

August 21, 2014
3 min read

off-the-cuff THHow often have you read a book review, say in The Sunday New York Times, and run into a phrase like, “Author John Doe, in this prescient new novel…”?  

off-the-cuff LARGEBy Allen Clark

How often have you read a book review, say in The Sunday New York Times, and run into a phrase like, “Author John Doe, in this prescient new novel…”?  I decided to keep track. Over a period of three months, the pattern was very clear. Book reviewers, sooner or later, fall back on a series of (usually) adjectives to describe an assigned book or author’s style.

The best place to look is the opening or closing paragraph or two. For example, “… in this gripping book” or “… a gorgeous, literary novel” or “… this sad, twisted tale” or “… this spirited and challenging book.” The word “this” seems to be a telltale sign.

Reviews of first-time novelists are a particular challenge.  “This debuting novel…” doesn’t really count. “In his notable first novel…” or “This compelling debut…” is a bit better, but barely. Sometimes, the reviewer just needs to use plain, every-day English, like this line from a recent review of a new novel, “… in this bighearted, winning book.” But the experienced reviewer needs to dig into his or her bag of adjectives and add dimension, like this recent setup: “In her perceptive, empathetic and often emotionally gripping new novel….” Load ‘em on!

Translations and biographies need a special touch. “A stylish translation” is a start, but it really needs some dressing up.  So did this opening comment about Susan Cheever’s new biography of E. E. Cummings, “… in her brief biography….” Brief” really doesn’t even qualify; it’s a kind of statistic with no sentiment or personality. Here’s a pitch with a little more on it, “… this sturdy, thoughtful, responsible” biography of Tennyson – at least the reviewer proffers three adjectives, and “sturdy” has a certain freshness about it.

There’s competition for the best, newest, and freshest descriptors. I thought this one (about a new John Wayne biography) deserved special mention: “In his authorized and enormously engaging new biography….” A good adverb can take a so-so adjective to new heights. This book isn’t just engaging or even very engaging; it’s enormously so.

From a review this spring, we get “This book, deeply unnerving and gorgeously tender.”  (We also learn a paragraph later, that this author’s previous novel was “a remorseless, forceful tale.”)  Best of all, Clair Vaye Watkins’ review of a first novel by Adrianne Harun, “This novel is a mesmerizing incantation, harrowing and hypnotic.” While not fully in the form I’m tracking (she sets the adjectives up following the verb “is”), three high-flying adjectives and one good noun get my vote for a Gold. Adjective proliferation, however, isn’t always a plus. I thought this one raised the bar a bit: “… a nervy, nerdy, dystopic thriller….”

 If I have a little free time, I think I’ll work on an app that let’s reviewers plug in what they think are the key points about books they’re reviewing, and the app will produce lists of all kinds of possible adjectives and let the reviewer pile up as many as he or she’d like. It should be “a uniquely utilitarian, ingeniously insightful, definitely defining, and cunningly clever” app.

Filed Under:
Subscribe and get freshly baked articles. Join the community!

baji999

marvelbet

krikya

Dbbet

Nagad88

Babu88

Six6s

Bhaggo

Elonbet

yono rummy

rummy glee

rummy perfect

rummy nabob

rummy modern

rummy wealth

jeetbuzz

iplwin

yono rummy

rummy deity

rummy app

betvisa

lotus365

hi88

8day

97win

n88

red88

king88

j88

i9bet

good88

nohu78

99ok

bet168

betvisa

satta king

satta matta matka

betvisa

mostplay

4rabet

leonbet

pin up

mostbet

rummy modern

Fastwin Login

Khela88

Fancywin

Jita Ace

Betjili

Betvisa

Babu88

jeetwin

nagad88

jaya9

joya 9

khela88

babu88

babu888

mostplay

marvelbet

baji999

abbabet

MCW

Jwin7

Glory Casino

Khela88

009Bet

Kuwin

SV66

78Win